We make over 50 flavors!
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry
Butter Pecan
Cherry Vanilla
Coffee
Coconut
Cookies & Cream
Cookie Dough
Mint Chip
Peach
Pistachio
Pralines & Cream
Rum Raisin
Specialty Flavors
Bellvale Bog
Dark chocolate ice cream with brownie dough and fudge swirl
Black Dirt Blast
Chocolate coffee ice cream with fudge and toffee pieces
Great White Way
White chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate chunks and raspberry swirl
Cheesecake
New York-style cheese cake ice cream with graham cracker swirl
S'mores
Graham cracker ice cream with marshmallow and chocolate swirl that takes you back to the campfire
In the Stix
French custard ice cream with Twix® candy bar pieces
Blueberries & Creme
Sweet creme ice cream with a
blueberry swirl
Pumpkin
Made with real pumpkin and a touch of spice - just like pumpkin pie
Maple Cinnamon
Made with real maple syrup and fresh ground cinnamon
Barn Boots
Peanut brittle and marshmallow in chocolate ice cream
Meadow Muffins
Brownie pieces and peanut butter swirl in dark chocolate ice cream
Lick the Bowl
Cake batter ice cream with fudge swirl
Calf Trax
Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter swirl and mini peanut butter cups
After Dinner Mint
Mint ice cream, a hint of chocolate with chocolate-covered mint pieces
Traditional Ice Cream Cakes
We begin with a layer of vanilla ice cream, then a layer of chocolate ice cream with chocolate crunch inside
Serves Price
Small 4-6 $ 13
Large 12-15 $ 23
Party 20-25 $ 28
Ice Cream Pie
Our delicious ice cream pies are available in two flavors: Great White Way (see description, left), in a graham cracker crust; and Bellvale Bog (see description, left), in a chocolate graham cracker crust.
$ 23
Please place cake and pie orders as far in advance as possible, by calling the Creamery at 845-988-1818. All custom cake requests need 7-10 days notice. Thank you.
Take Out Containers Price
Quarts $8
5-quart pail $20
2 1/2 gallon tub $35
Low-Carb Selections:
Desserts made from reduced-sugar ice cream, using Splenda®
Sorbet Selections – Dairy-Free
Sorbet is a fruit-based dessert that uses juice as its base. It's preferred by people who are either allergic to dairy or opting not to eat dairy-based desserts.

Be sure to check the menu board or call ahead to ensure your favorite flavor is available. We make fresh batches daily and may experience unpredictable demand for certain flavors!

Low Fat Vanilla Frozen Yogurt
We also offer delicious frozen yogurt, with assorted toppings.

Tel: 845-988-1818 | info@bellvalefarms.com |
1390 Route 17A, Warwick, NY 10990 © Bellvale Farms. All rights reserved. | Web Design