Ice Cream Flavors: We make over 50!

Be sure to check the menu board or call ahead to ensure your favorite flavor is available. We make fresh batches daily and may experience unpredictable demand for certain flavors!

Basic Flavors

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Strawberry
  • Butter Pecan
  • Cherry Vanilla
  • Coffee
  • Coconut
  • Cookies & Cream
  • Cookie Dough
  • Mint Chip
  • Peach
  • Pistacchio
  • Pralines & Cream
  • Rum Raisin

Take-Out Containers

  • Quarts: $ 9
  • 5-quart pail: $ 25
  • 2 1/2 gallon tub: $ 35

Specialty Flavors

  • Bellvale Bog: Dark chocolate ice cream with brownie dough and fudge swirl
  • Black Dirt Blast: Chocolate coffee ice cream with fudge and toffee pieces
  • Great White Way: White chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate chunks and raspberry swirl
  • Cheesecake: New York-style cheese cake ice cream with graham cracker swirl
  • S'mores: Graham cracker ice cream with marshmallow and chocolate swirl that takes you back to the campfire
  • In the Stix: French custard ice cream with Twix® candy bar pieces
  • Blueberries & Creme: Sweet creme ice cream with a blueberry swirl
  • Pumpkin: Made with real pumpkin and a touch of spice - just like pumpkin pie
  • Maple Cinnamon: Made with real maple syrup and fresh ground cinnamon
  • Barn Boots: Peanut brittle and marshmallow in chocolate ice cream
  • Meadow Muffins: Brownie pieces and peanut butter swirl in dark chocolate ice cream
  • Lick the Bowl: Cake batter ice cream with fudge swirl
  • Calf Trax: Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter swirl and mini peanut butter cups
  • After Dinner Mint: Mint ice cream, a hint of chocolate with chocolate-covered mint pieces

Traditional Ice Cream Cakes

We begin with a layer of vanilla ice cream, then a layer of chocolate ice cream with chocolate crunch inside.
  • Small - serves 4-6. Price: $ 13
  • Large - serves 12-15. Price: $ 23
  • Party - serves 20-25. Price: $ 28

Ice Cream Pie

Our delicious ice cream pies are available in two flavors: Great White Way (see description, left), in a graham cracker crust; and Bellvale Bog (see description, left), in a chocolate graham cracker crust.
  • Ice Cream Pie: $ 23
Please place cake and pie orders as far in advance as possible, by calling the Creamery at 845-988-1818. All custom cake requests need 7-10 days notice. Thank you.

Low-Carb Selections:

Desserts made from reduced-sugar ice cream, using Splenda®

Sorbet Selections – Dairy-Free

Sorbet is a fruit-based dessert that uses juice as its base. It's preferred by people who are either allergic to dairy or opting not to eat dairy-based desserts.

Vanilla Frozen Yogurt

We also offer delicious frozen yogurt, with assorted toppings